sh404SEF, JoomSEF and AceSEF

After we released AceSEF, we recieved too much questions asking about why we needed to develop a new SEF component because of there were great SEF components avaliable. Well, yes, there were SEF components but they either were just generating SEF URLs (sh404SEF) OR didn't fullfil the needs (JoomSEF).

Click on this link for the updated Part 2 of this comparison.

Here it is the comparison table of the most used sh404SEF and JoomSEF components versus AceSEF.

	sh404SEF	JoomSEF	AceSEF
Free Version
Free Support
Generates SEF URLs
Overrides Joomla! core files which can break functionality	Yes	No	No
Easy-to-use graphical user interface	Worst	Good	Best
Written according Joomla! 1.5 Framework & MVC Standarts
Written 100% in modular way
3rd Party extensions installation and management
Sitemap (XML) for ALL components
Meta Manager in batch mode
Advanced SEF URL rewriting methods management
Basic SEF URL rewriting, no plugin obligation to make SEF
Supports Joomla! 1.5 router.php files	Paid ver.
100% accurated pagination
Alias option for ALL components
Managed automatic meta tags generation
Duplicated URLs management	Hard-to-use	Good	Easy-to-use
Unique numerical URLs for duplicated URLs
Advances SEF URLs filtration in backend
Migration from other SEF components without losing old URLs
Automatic update(new version) checker
Upgrade page
Customisable 404 page
Supports Google News numbering	Simple	Extended	Extended
Queries for FrontPage (cache on)	24	27	31
Redirect from non-SEF to SEF URL