sh404SEF, JoomSEF and AceSEF
After we released AceSEF, we recieved too much questions asking about why we needed to develop a new SEF component because of there were great SEF components avaliable. Well, yes, there were SEF components but they either were just generating SEF URLs (sh404SEF) OR didn't fullfil the needs (JoomSEF).
Here it is the comparison table of the most used sh404SEF and JoomSEF components versus AceSEF.
Here it is the comparison table of the most used sh404SEF and JoomSEF components versus AceSEF.
| sh404SEF | JoomSEF | AceSEF | |
| Free Version |
|||
| Free Support |
|||
| Generates SEF URLs |
|||
| Overrides Joomla! core files which can break functionality |
Yes | No | No |
| Easy-to-use graphical user interface |
Worst | Good | Best |
| Written according Joomla! 1.5 Framework & MVC Standarts |
|||
| Written 100% in modular way |
|||
| 3rd Party extensions installation and management |
|||
| Sitemap (XML) for ALL components |
|||
| Meta Manager in batch mode |
|||
| Advanced SEF URL rewriting methods management |
|||
| Basic SEF URL rewriting, no plugin obligation to make SEF |
|||
| Supports Joomla! 1.5 router.php files |
Paid ver. | ||
| 100% accurated pagination | |||
| Alias option for ALL components |
|||
| Managed automatic meta tags generation |
|||
| Duplicated URLs management |
Hard-to-use | Good | Easy-to-use |
| Unique numerical URLs for duplicated URLs |
|||
| Advances SEF URLs filtration in backend |
|||
| Migration from other SEF components without losing old URLs |
|||
| Automatic update(new version) checker |
|||
| Upgrade page |
|||
| Customisable 404 page |
|||
| Supports Google News numbering |
Simple | Extended |
Extended |
| Queries for FrontPage (cache on) |
24 | 27 |
31 |
| Redirect from non-SEF to SEF URL |


Comments
Both solutions are automatic, you can set the replacement chars in AceSEF=>Confiugration page.
You mean I have two solutions
-replace it manually in new SEF URL or
- Unicode URL does it automatically?
You can replace the with the latin one or enable the Unicode URLs feature of AceSEF.
Artio = JoomSEF . In fact the product name is ARTIO JoomSEF http://bit.ly/W40X2
Yo probe los 3 y definitivamente es muy superior AceSEF, facil, rapido.
Luis Cardenas
Costa Rica
I tested the 3 products and the best opton is AceSEF, quic instalation, very user friendly and powerful.
Also, much 3pd component's sef-extension are crypted too: I have to wait the sef-ext. upgrade in order to upgrade installed components.
It would be cool if you compare AceSEF and SEF Advance on this points.
Add comment